I NO LONGER ask people who I’ve just met the question: “Where are you from?”
Until recently, if I met a person with an accent that suggested they spoke another language, I’d ask the question out of genuine curiosity and interest.
I’ve lived abroad myself and was often asked this and the response to my “I’m from Scotland” was always positive and led to interesting follow-up questions. So I saw this question as a friendly one, displaying an interest in who the person was.
But times, I fear, are quickly changing and those of us who cherish diversity and a welcoming society cannot look away as I believe something deeply unpleasant and frightening is happening on our land.
Ever since my early days, I’ve been fascinated by history. As I studied different periods and different countries, I became aware of the similarities in behaviour and events, even within different historical epochs.
One constant theme was the way people with wealth and power would maintain and entrench their position by otherising one group within society and scapegoating them, blaming them for the ills of society and making their persecution seem the solution to the problems in people’s lives.
It’s a trick done to divert people’s gaze and anger away from the powerful culprits who were the true cause of injustice. It’s a trick especially favoured by dictators and the super-rich. The othering of a group of people allowed the persecution of them to become normalised and accepted, it dehumanised them in the eyes of the many, which in turn helped to justify discrimination and, eventually, atrocities.
History is full of such examples and the mystery for me as I studied it was why did people down the centuries fall for such an obvious trick? I know we can fool someone by pointing to something behind them to distract their attention, then steal what’s in front of them. But usually that person will be wise the next time.
Yet history shows us that this trick has successfully worked for thousands of years. Why hasn’t everyone gotten wise to it, especially when history shows us the ultimate consequences? I know the trick never fools everyone, but it doesn’t have to. History also shows us that not everyone needs to be fooled, just enough.
It’s left me asking the question, how can we better see through this 'othering' and instead see the common humanity we all share? This question led me to a poem called 'Where I’m From', by George Ella Lyon.
The poem seeks to redefine the question of where you are from by making it all about the many things in your life that have defined who you are, such as smells, food, experiences, values, emotions, places and people. It’s a poem which has inspired many to copy the format to explore where they are from.
While it may focus on a person’s individual identity, the result is deeply humanising because while everyone’s details will differ, the humanity is shared. It’s an antidote to labels like 'alien', 'one of them', 'illegal', 'garbage', 'foreign', 'immigrant' or any other label that is often used when people are asked where they are from.
I won’t share George Ella Lyon’s poem here, you can find it and read it yourself easily online.
But here is mine.
'I am from the taste of salt in my nose and the roar of the sea in my ears.
I am from the volcano which has made the land which has been my cradle.
I am from a boat called Tangus with her red and yellow colours of memory.
I am from the smell of coal smoke and my father’s woodbine ash.
I am from the smell of French toast in the morning.
I’m from "life is too short not to be kind”.
I am from the smell of incense and mint sauce on Sundays.
I am from a home of music, safety and love, until it wasn’t.
I am from grief and “you are the man of the house now, mustn’t cry”.
I am from night rides on my bicycle, cold hands, warmed soul.
I am from the pear tree I climbed, who gave me roots in a new place.
I am from fear and anxiety of never being enough.
I am from being on the wrong road, then finding a path.
I am from maternity hospital, holding my newborn children, five miracles.
I am from poverty but still rich.
I am from my hat, who knows me better than myself.
I am from the sound of rain on canvas and the smell of summer dew.
I am from the sound of children’s laughter, wonder and awe.
I am from the love of a woman who finally found me.
I am from a quiet wood, listening to birdsong and believing they sing for me.'
That’s mine. You could try to write yours.
Perhaps if we do ask “where are you from?” we should do it in this way, then the trick will be less easy to play on us.
Share