Tim's Tales: The last man executed for heresy in Scotland

The Old Tolbooth, Edinburgh, in an engraving based on an 18th-century painting by Alexander Naysmith <i>(Image: Alexander Naysmith)</i>
The Old Tolbooth, Edinburgh, in an engraving based on an 18th-century painting by Alexander Naysmith (Image: Alexander Naysmith)
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

IT WAS January 8, 1697, and it was freezing cold.

Thomas’s feet were damp and aching as he was frogmarched through the ice and snow from the Tolbooth on Edinburgh’s High Street to the Gallow Lee, halfway to Leith, at a place now called Shrubhill.

Now covered in houses, it used to be an open raised ground with shrubs and grass, and it was here that the gallows were erected.

Thomas Aikenhead was only 20 years old, a medical student at Edinburgh University, but his life was about to end.

As he hobbled down Leith Walk, a crowd of people followed him, some in silence, others jeering and saying he was getting what he deserved. They’d come to spectate his end.

Among them were dozens of ministers from the Church of Scotland. These Christian men had been instrumental in securing the death penalty for this now terrified young man. They wanted to gleefully witness his final agony, for they had demanded Thomas suffer a “vigorous execution” so it would be a lesson for others.

What thoughts were swirling through Thomas’s mind during that walk, we can only imagine. I think he must have been experiencing a sense of disbelief that a humorous remark about the weather had come to this.

Just five months before, in August 1696, Thomas had been walking down the High Street with three fellow students whom he considered friends. Although it was August, the weather was dreich and unpleasantly cold. This time was a time later called 'the Little Ice Age', when temperatures were much lower than today or previous centuries.

They chatted as they walked and, when they passed the recently built Tron Kirk, Thomas huddled into his coat, looked up at the grey, cold sky, and said: “I wish I was warming myself in that place Ezra called Hell, rather than freezing here in Edinburgh.” Ezra is a key figure in the Bible’s Old Testament.

His fellow students glanced at each other but said nothing and they continued their journey. No doubt Thomas and his friends found a place to get warm in a tavern or one of the coffee houses which were sprouting up. Thomas then went home not knowing the storm brewing for him.

The following day, Thomas was arrested. One of his 'friends', called Mungo Craig, had reported his words and Thomas was imprisoned in the infamous Tolbooth, accused of blasphemy.

It can certainly be said that Thomas had been naïve in the way he openly spoke, but he was with friends. However, Scotland in those days was a harsh theocracy, with state and religion deeply intertwined. Many in the past had died because their worship of the same god differed from the official religion of the time. Thomas was questioning or disparaging the foundations of religious faith itself, which was an added threat to the power of both church and state. Those in power did not want such ideas to take hold.

But such ideas were indeed taking hold. In the coffee houses around Parliament Square, under the shadow of St Giles and Parliament House, discussions which were to later form the basis of Enlightenment thinking were becoming more common. Reason and critical thinking were gradually dissolving the foundations of theocratic power, which is why books were banned and people who dared share such ideas were prosecuted for blasphemy.

In fact, Thomas wasn’t the only one languishing in the Tolbooth accused of blasphemy in late 1696. He shared a cell with John Frazer, an Edinburgh bookseller who had been accused of telling people that “there was no god” and that the “beliefs in established religion were made up to frighten folks and keep them in order”.

Frazer was punished under the Blasphemy Act of 1685, in which the first offence was imprisonment and the wearing of a sackcloth to symbolise repentance. Under this act, a second offence would also impose a fine, while the death penalty would only be imposed if there was a third offence.

So we can imagine the shock and despair when Thomas was told that the prosecutor, Sir James Stewart, who was Lord Advocate, was also charging him under an earlier act of 1661, which carried the death penalty even for a first offence.

Why was this poor young lad being singled out for such merciless punishment? The answer was Stewart wanted to make an example of Thomas, to instil fear and terror to ensure conformity. The tide of rational truth-seeking had to be stopped.

Witnesses were gathered to prove that Thomas was guilty, including fellow students whom Thomas had thought friends. They testified that Thomas had called the Old Testament “Ezra’s fables” and denied the veracity of the New Testament.

Thomas could not deny this, for he was a clever and enquiring young medical student who had read widely, trying to understand the background and origins of the faith he had been brought up in. He’d read the works of authors frowned upon by church and state authorities, including The Oracles of Reason by Charles Blount, which claimed reason rather than blind faith was the path to truth.

Thomas had no money to hire a lawyer, so he tried to defend himself, but of course he had no hope against such a formidable prosecutor. After the guilty verdict, he pled for his life, saying he repented. Two kirk ministers and two members of the privy council petitioned on his behalf. But the privy council would only consider a reprieve if the General Assembly of the Church of Scotland agreed.

It happened to be in session at the time and surely these esteemed representatives of Christ’s teachings would show compassion for a terrified young man who had publicly repented. They did not; instead, they declared that Thomas should be subjected to a “vigorous execution”.

And so these 'men of God' watched with satisfaction as young Thomas breathed his last at the end of a rope.

But this was the darkest moment before the dawn, for Thomas Aikenhead was the last person in this country to be executed for heresy. And while he didn’t live to see it, within what could have been his lifetime, that dawn brought the ideas of the Enlightenment, also called the Age of Reason.

On his last day alive, Thomas wrote a letter for those close to him, in which he said: “It is a principle innate and co-natural to every man to have an insatiable inclination to the truth, and to seek for it, as for hid treasure.”

Those words were written 328 years ago, but I think they are as relevant as ever.

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos