'Not much to do' in Port Seton, Councillor Donna Collins claims

Karen Skinner was originally refused permission for a change of use for her ground-floor property at The Promenade, Port Seton, because it shared a communal entrance with other flats in the building.

But a meeting of East Lothian Council’s Local Review Body this week heard that it had been operating for some time with no objections raised by neighbours.

And councillors questioned the type of people who would let the ground-floor flat, with one pointing out that there was little to do in the community.

Councillor Donna Collins told the meeting: “No offence to Port Seton, but there is not much to do there.”

'Not a major impact'

The review body heard from Councillor Jeremy Findlay that a recent survey by area partnerships had estimated that there were just 13 short-term holiday lets in the Preston Seton Gosford ward, where Port Seton lies – equating to three per cent of all private rentals.

He said: “This is an extremely small number which does not have a major impact on the amenity of residents.”

In her appeal, Mrs Skinner pointed out that the two-bedroom ground-floor flat had a private back door leading directly out onto the beach promenade which guests "preferred to use".

However, review body chair Councillor Andrew Forrest pointed out that the lock key for holidaymakers arriving at the flat was at the main entrance into the communal stairwell.

Planners refused the change of use in June after ruling that the communal front entrance to the flat would mean a high turnover of people using it and a change to the amenity of the property for other residents.

'Regular turnover'

They said: “Such a regular turnover of users/occupants would change the nature of comings and goings not only to the application property itself but also within the communal entrance and hallway of the residential building.

“Most users/occupants of the holiday let would have a degree of luggage or other property to take through the communal entrance which in itself would lead to a level of disturbance and nuisance not associated with the permanent/long-term residential use of the property.

“It is accepted that permanent residents may also make noise but they tend to keep their luggage in their homes and do not move them with the same frequency as regularly changing guests.”

Councillor Collins told the meeting that she would support the appeal and overturn the planning officer's decision but warned other holiday let owners not to expect the same decision in the future.

She said: “Each case is considered on its own merit.”

The review body granted the change of use by two members to one.